Galveston County Daily News April 2, 2013
Medical Discovery News
By Drs. David Niesel and Norbert Herzog
Ask expectant parents what kind of child they want, and one word almost always comes up: healthy. So, the possibility that a new baby may carry a genetic disorder can be understandably devastating. But a recent research from the Oregon Health Sciences Center may offer a unique approach to actually preventing certain types of genetic diseases – the three-parent child.
When they invented this approach, researchers were thinking of the 4,000 children born each year with genetic defects in their mitochondrial DNA. These children consequentially develop one or more of 50 known mitochondrial diseases, many with devastating symptoms like stroke, epilepsy, dementia, blindness, deafness and kidney or heart failure. Mitochondria are the power plants of the cell, producing the energy needed for a cell to function. Each mitochondrion has its own DNA independent and outside of a person’s chromosomal DNA, which is housed in the cell’s nucleus. Diseases affecting mitochondria are difficult to treat, so this new way of actually preventing them is a welcome, while controversial, innovation.
First, eggs are obtained from the mother and a female donor. The nucleus from the egg of the natural mother is removed, separating her chromosomal genetic information from her mitochondria, which would have been passed on with the mutation to the child. This nucleus is then transferred to the donor egg, from which the nucleus and genetic information have been removed and discarded. The result is an egg with the nucleus and genes of the natural mother and the functioning mitochondria of the donor.
Then the egg is fertilized with the natural father’s sperm (which does not contribute any mitochondria to an egg), producing a fertilized egg with the DNA of the natural mother and father and the healthy mitochondrial DNA of the donor. However, the contribution of the donor egg’s mitochondrial DNA is not much – the mitochondrial genome accounts for only 1 percent of the total DNA present in a human cell. So, the embryo will have genetic information from three people. The future child would share the genetic characteristics of the mother and father but have the mitochondrial genetic makeup of the egg donor.
In recent studies, scientists removed the nuclei and the DNA within from 65 human eggs and replaced them with donated nuclei. After fertilization, just under half of the eggs grew to a 100-cell stage called a blastocyst, the precursor to an embryo. This is the same rate seen for unaltered fertilized eggs. While the blastocysts were not implanted into wombs, they could have eventually developed into three-parent children. The change to their mitochondrial DNA would be permanent, and they could pass on the functional mitochondria to future generations.
While this is huge progress for treating genetic disease, it also raises some significant ethical questions, such as whether the technique could eventually be used to create “designer” babies whose DNA has been manipulated to meet parents’ wishes. This development holds great potential as an advance in genetic therapy, but its accompanying controversy means scientists should take steps to prevent abuses.
Medical Discovery News is a weekly radio and print broadcast highlighting medical and scientific breakthroughs hosted by professors Norbert Herzog of the Frank H. Netter School of Medicine at Quinnipiac University in Hamden, Conn, and David Niesel of the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston. Learn more at www.medicaldiscoverynews.com.